Posts Tagged: Scotland


18
Dec 09

The Scottish season so far: the national side

As we begin the run up to the end of 2009, Inside Left looks back on an interesting season so far in Scottish football. This season can best be summarized as ‘troublesome’, as our clubs struggle in European competition and our chairmen and directors struggle in the boardroom. And with financial trouble never off the radar, what is the future for Scottish football?

We begin though, with a look back at the national side’s efforts this year, and look forward to a difficult, but hopefully rosy (tartan?) future.

Continue reading →


2
Dec 09

On This Day in Scottish Football

Scotland concluded their 1988 European Championship qualifying campaign with a goalless draw against Luxembourg, and on this day in 1911, a young Patsy Gallagher made his debut for Celtic.

Continue reading →


20
Nov 09

On Messrs McGregor, Ferguson and Boyd

There’s very little that surprises us here at Inside Left Towers these days.

When we first heard SFA Chief Executive Gordon Smith blithely announce – only days after he sacked his national team manager – that those pariahs of the Scottish game, Allan McGregor, Barry Ferguson and Kris Boyd would be eligible for selection by any future Scotland manager, we shrugged our shoulders and moved on.

Continue reading →


18
Nov 09

The SFA and the search for the next manager of Scotland

Now that the bunting has been torn down from between the tenements and the houses and the last of the party revellers bundled into a taxi for the long ride home, the mandarins at the SFA find themselves in a situation that gets less unique with every tournament that passes Scottish football by.

Continue reading →


17
Nov 09

Thank you Mr Burley. Send in the next man please …

George Burley was finally removed from his post as manager of the Scotland national side this evening, bringing to an end the managerial run of a man who in the end “managed” to make even Berti Vogts look good, and whose dismal record in charge of the national squad is second only to the late John Prentice in 1966, who didn’t even manage a single victory (although Prentice at least managed a 1-1 draw with Brazil).

Continue reading →


28
Sep 09

The Great Scottish Football Debate

Ahead of former First Minister Henry McLeish’s eagerly anticipated Scottish Football review, Stirling University will this evening host a question-time style debate featuring the main men in Scottish football.

Although this particular panel has no authority, the opportunity to quiz some of the people who are involved with football in Scotland at a high level is certainly welcome, and their answers eagerly anticipated by this site.

Chaired by Jim Spence, the participants to this public debate are:

Henry McLeish (former First Minister, instigator of the latest review into Scottish football)
Gordon Smith (SFA Chief Exec)
Iain Blair (SPL Operations Director)
David Longmuir (SFL Chief Exec)
Fraser Wishart (PFA Scotland Chief Executive )
James Proctor (Supporters Direct Development Manager )

We’ve spent some time thinking about the issues we think need to be addressed, attached it to the nearest homing pigeon and sent it off to Stirling. Here are the questions we’ve forwarded to the panel.

1/ Does the panel admit that Scottish football is in a poor state and that it needs  a complete overhaul?

2/ How does the panel think the task force led by Henry McLeish will make any difference when many previous attempts to reform Scottish football appear to have failed?

3/ Would the panel recommend the implementation of the same League structure and the same League management structure if Scottish football started from scratch today?

4/ Does the panel support the idea of a pyramid system with relegation from the SFL 3rd Division and promotion from the HFL/West of Scotland Premier League?

5/ We hear a lot about the youth systems in place in European countries such as The Netherlands. Does the panel feel that such systems actually work, and would similar scheme work in Scotland. If not, why not?

6/ The Old Firm have been dominating the league for many years. What does the panel suggest would bridge the gap between the Old Firm and the rest of the SPL?

7/ Although attendances in the SPL are reasonably stable, the majority of games are never sold out. What does the panel suggest should happen to encourage greater numbers back to the stadiums?

8/ What does the panel suggest should be done to stop clubs from overspending and potentially going into administration?

9/ On what grounds would the panel oppose moves by the Old Firm to leave the SPL and play in England?

10/ Does the panel support the idea of a longer winter break and a shorter summer break?

We’re interested in the answers the panel give, providing our homing pigeon make it to the venue of course.

If you think there are any other issues that need to be addressed or you have your opinions about the 10 questions we’ve posted here, feel free to leave a comment and we’ll post them on the site.

‘Scottish Football under the spotlight’ will be held at the Macrobert Arts Centre, on the University of Stirling campus, on Monday 28 September, kicking off at 6.30pm.

Tickets are free. Confirm your attendance via e-mail to sportevents@stir.ac.uk or call 01786 466 498. Please provide your name, contact details, a suggested question for the panel if you wish and which team/organisation you represent if appropriate.


10
Sep 09

Scotland 0-1 The Netherlands

You know, it could all have been so different.

When I wrote the tweet, you know, the one about how I think Scotland will score, I genuinely felt we would. Holland where not great, even the Dutch newspapers today said so. Scotland where not much better, but they where playing with the sort of passion and commitment that’s been sadly lacking in their earlier displays.

They ran after every ball, and made sure the Dutch had as little time on the ball as possible to ensure that their normally crisp passing and movement did not have a chance to take over the game. The Dutch certainly had the better of the opening exchanges, with Dirk Kuijt hitting the post from long range, but the harassing style of Scotland’s play unsettled the Group 9 winners.

Scotland had a few chances to score – Scott Brown somehow managed to get himself on the end of a Naismith cross only to see the ball go inches past the wrong side of the post. Miller hit the crossbar, but by the far the best chance of the game came when Naismith fired in a low shot that took Dutch rookie keeper Vorm by surprise: the FC Utrecht keeper, making his debut for Holland, managed to tip Naismith’s cross onto the post. The rebound fell kindly for Kenny Miller, but his shot was fired right at the keeper who had done well to recover.

After all those chances, and with the Hampden crowd getting behind Burley’s men, it seemed almost a given that Scotland would score. But the game slowly turned as the Scots, tiring of the search for that elusive goal, started making mistakes. And it was a mistake by veteran defender David Weir that resulted in Holland scoring. His clumsy attempt at a clearance following a long ball out of the Dutch defence allowed Eljero Elia, the 22 year-old SV Hamburg striker to collect the ball and work his way neatly past Marshal.

So, that’s it. Another World Cup we’ll not be attending.

The finger pointing will start soon. It’s in our human nature to find a cause for the lack of success in this campaign. Some have called for the heads of SFA President and SFA Chief Executive, George Peat and Gordon Smith. There’s certainly a case to be made.

As the men in charge of the maintenance and development of the Scottish game, there’s not been much evidence of their ability to steady the ship and steer us in the right direction. Falling attendances, clubs, sponsors and TV companies have gone bust, accusations of cash for votes and board members with dual (financial) interests in clubs (all of which against the rules of their own organisation by the way), not to mention a Chief Executive that is quite willing to lay the blame of a poor World Cup campaign at the manager and an obscure, and often injured Wolves striker, point to a Football Association that has no idea what it’s doing, other than keeping the status quo.

What about George Burley? We’ve never been a fan of his over at Inside Left. He just never seemed to radiate the sort of authority and respect that I’d like to see in a manager. I suspect that feeling is also felt amongst the squad. You just can’t imagine Boyd walking out on Stein or McGregor and Ferguson going on a bender with Walter Smith still in charge.

What about the game itself? Our football is shocking. Technically inept and lacking any imagination, our football is of the ‘lump it up and see’ variety. Our attempts at a passing game is laughable to say the least, and it’s a strange world indeed when the best thing the world can say about our team is how good our goalie is. When he plays.

Years ago, Scotland strikers where feared, while our goalies where the butt of endless jokes. Nowadays, it seems to be the other way around. It would have been easier for Miller to score from Naismith’s rebound than to miss – a painful reminder, if one where needed, of Chris Uwelumo’s miss against Norway.

The answer to our problems probably lies in all three. We can sack the SFA Board, but you’d only be replacing it with more cronies. You can sack the managers, but he can only do as much as he can with the material he’s given with – a pig in a dress, after all, is still a pig. And you can improve the quality of the football only by the way in which kids are coached and the way in which coaches are coached.

We’ve a few more years to think about how to get Scottish football back on the rails.

The great hope is that we’ll have sorted something out by then to make sure we don’t struggle against the Iceland’s, Norway’s and Macedonia’s of this world. Judging by our clubs performances in Europe however, the fear of another struggling campaign are very real.

The draw for the UEFA Euro 2012 qualifying round will take place in Poland on 7 February next year. Where we end up depends on our League coefficient, the ranking of our league based on the performances of our club sides in Europe over the past 5 years. Scotland currently lie in 13th place, and with only Celtic and Rangers able to have any influence on that ranking between now and the draw, the chances are that we’ll be lumped in with the same teams we played for this World Cup Qualifying campaign.

And we all know how that one ended.


8
Sep 09

Scotland the Brave

Here we are at last.

The opening-day defeat in the blazing heat in Macedonia and our subsequent 2-0 win in the return fixture on Saturday neatly bookends a campaign that started almost a year ago to the day, and which boils down to a single game at Hampden Park tomorrow night.

Facing the Scots are The Netherlands, a team which qualified back in June and who sit top of the table with maximum points. On paper you’d think there’s nothing much for the Dutch to play for, but the feeling amongst the Dutch camp is that a perfect score – 8 wins out of 8 – will see them enter the draw for the World Cup group stage as one of the seeded teams.

For the Dutch this would be an added incentive to go for a victory against the Scots, as being seeded essentially means avoiding the other big teams in the competition, such as Germany, Spain and Brazil until at least the second round.

That the Dutch are taking this campaign – and the game against Scotland – seriously is evidenced by the fact that they played a friendly against Japan on Saturday. The Dutch won 3-0 with goals from Robin van Persie and Klaas-Jan Huntelaar (who also scored against the Scotland in the 3-0 win in Amsterdam) with Wesley Sneijder also getting his name on the score sheet.

The game was not a vintage one however. Coach Bert van Marwijk was not happy with the performance, especially in the first half when the Dutch failed to break down a solid Japan defence. Van Marwijk later said that the game against Japan on Saturday was arguably the worst Dutch performance he’s ever seen, but it shows the strength and depth of the side when they recovered their form in the second half to secure a win.

It was certainly not the same performance that saw them go 2-0 up before half-time against a full-strength England side. Dirk Kuyt and Rafael van der Vaart pounced on defensive errors from Rio Ferdinand and Gareth Barry in the first half, but a spirited comeback from Fabio Capello’s side earned them a 2-2 draw – Jermaine Defoe getting both goals.

That Holland are capable of poor performances was shown during their game against Iceland. Following on from solid performances against Macedonia (4-0) and Scotland (3-0), a 2-1 win which saw the Dutch cruise into a 2-0 lead before half-time (with goals from Nigel de Jong and Marc Van Bommel) resulted in scathing articles in the Dutch press, critical of the lackluster display, especially in the second half when Holland failed to kill the game off, and which allowed Iceland to get on the score sheet with 2 minutes left to play.  That result assured qualification, but that didn’t stop The Dutch from taking their foot of the pedal: in their next game, four days later against Norway, they recovered their form to win 2-0.

Compared to the Dutch, Scotland’s efforts to reach World Cup 2010 reads like the 12 Labours of Hercules. Slaying the Hydra, capturing the Cretan Bull or stealing the apples of the Hesperides sounds like a walk in the park compared to getting Scotland to South Africa.

A series of scandals and dressing-room bust-ups must make Burley lie awake at night wondering just what on earth he’s gotten himself in to. It’s a credit to the man that he’s lasted as long as he has, given the criticism he’s been receiving from all quarters. That criticism took a turn for the absurd last week when George Peat, president of the SFA, came out in the press with comments blaming Chris Iwelumo for the mess Scotland’s World Cup campaign is in, and that Burley’s job is on the line if Scotland do not finish second in the group.

Sheer stupidity or clever psychology? Who knows, but whichever it was, it worked. Burley and the troops got their act together to record a cracking 2-0 win over Macedonia at Hampden and which featured one of the greatest goals ever seen by a player in a Scotland shirt.

Somewhat predictably in these competitions, it’s not just the tactics board that determines qualification, but a calculator and a brain the size of Sutherland, because even if Scotland do accomplish the 13th Labour of Hercules, i.e., beat Holland, it still requires a series of results of byzantine proportions to see Scotland through to South Africa.

The win over Macedonia pushed Scotland back in 6th place in the table of ‘Best Second-placed Teams’. Should Scotland beat the Netherlands at Hampden tomorrow, it would need Northern Ireland to lose to Slovakia, and Slovenia and Poland to draw in Group 3. That series of results would basically ensure that no team from Group 3 (in which Northern Ireland are our biggest rivals) will qualify for the remaining play-off place.

One down, two to go…

Our other rivals for a coveted place in the play-offs in November are Bosnia/Herzegovina (who need four points from their remaining games against Spain, Turkey and Estonia to qualify), Sweden (who also need four points from their games against Denmark and Albania), and Hungary, who have games against Denmark and Portugal to come.

All of this speculation is moot of course unless Scotland does the hardest thing: beat Holland. Even if history has not always been on Scotland’s side in this fixture, we’ve done it before, so why not again? Now, more than ever, Scotland needs to show the world that they can compete against the best in the world. The game will not be easy, and the Dutch will not roll-over just because they’ve qualified; as we’ve seen, they have something to play for too.

In the cold light of day, with the exception of the goalkeeper, we’re outclassed in every department, but what we lack in skill, we make up for in determination and passion, especially on these big occasions. Scotland, as underdog, at Hampden, should make for a dangerous opponent.

Holland, beware.